Is Reverse Osmosis Worth It on Well Water?

RO makes excellent drinking water and does nothing at all for the rest of your house. Whether it is worth $450 to $1,100 depends entirely on which problem you actually have.

Reverse osmosis gets recommended for almost every well water complaint, and it is genuinely excellent at one job. The trouble is that the job it does is much narrower than most people realise when they buy one.

The short version. RO treats the water at one tap. It will not stop staining in your tubs, scale in your water heater or a smell at the shower, because none of that water goes through it.

What RO actually is

A membrane with pores fine enough to let water molecules through and hold back almost everything else: dissolved minerals, metals, nitrates, most of what a well can carry. It sits under a sink with its own small faucet, produces slowly into a storage tank, and sends some water to the drain as part of the process.

At $450 to $1,100 fitted it is the cheapest piece of treatment equipment in this article, and the water it makes is the best you will get out of a tap.

When it is the right answer

• Drinking and cooking water is the complaint. If the rest of the house is fine and you just want better water in a glass, this is it.
• You are buying bottled water. The arithmetic gets compelling quickly.
• A test came back with nitrates or high dissolved solids. RO is the practical answer for drinking water, and it is worth adding bacteria and nitrate testing if anyone in the house is pregnant or the well is shallow.
• The icemaker is making cloudy or off-tasting ice. Run the RO line to the fridge while it is being fitted rather than as a second visit.

When it is the wrong answer

Here is the conversation we have most often, and it saves people real money.

Somebody has orange staining in every toilet, a rotten-egg smell in the shower, and laundry going grey. They have been told reverse osmosis will fix their well water. It will not touch any of it.

Your toilet, your shower and your washing machine are not connected to the RO unit. They get the same untreated well water they always did. What those symptoms need is whole home filtration at $2,200 to $4,500 for iron and sulfur, or a water softener at $1,800 to $3,500 for hardness, and the test is what decides which.

RO on top of that is a fine addition. RO instead of it is money spent on the wrong problem.

What kills RO membranes early on the Shore

The membrane is the expensive, fragile part, and it fouls fast on exactly what Shore well water carries: iron, sediment, and hardness.

An RO unit fitted to untreated well water will work beautifully for a while and then slow down, and the owner replaces a membrane every couple of years wondering why. The pre-filters exist to protect it, but they are a last line, not a substitute for treating the water properly upstream.

This is the practical reason the order matters. If you are going to do both, do the whole-home treatment first and fit the RO afterwards, and it will last.

The things nobody mentions before you buy

• It produces slowly. The tank is what gives you a glass on demand, not the membrane.
• It needs a drain connection and cabinet space. Both are worth planning before anything is drilled.
• It sends water to the drain. Worth knowing on a septic system.
• It removes minerals you may want back. Remineralizing cartridges exist if you prefer the taste.

So, worth it?

For drinking water on a well that has otherwise been treated properly: yes, easily, and it is the change people notice daily.

As a fix for staining, scale or smell: no, and anyone selling it to you on that basis has not looked at your water.

See reverse osmosis installation, the full price list, or water treatment and filtration.

Is reverse osmosis worth it?

For drinking and cooking water, yes, it is the best water you will get out of a tap. For staining, scale or smell through the house, no, because RO only treats the one sink it is fitted under.

How much does reverse osmosis cost?

$450 to $1,100 fitted under the sink, with its own faucet. Cartridge changes run within the $60 to $200 a year that treatment cartridges generally cost.

Does reverse osmosis waste water?

It sends some water to the drain alongside what it produces. That is inherent to the process, and it is worth knowing about on a septic system.

Will RO remove iron and hardness?

It removes them from the water at that one tap, and it pays for it. Iron and hardness foul RO membranes quickly, which is why whole home treatment belongs ahead of it rather than after it.

Does RO take good minerals out too?

Yes, largely. Some people prefer the taste with a little mineral content put back, and remineralizing cartridges exist for exactly that.

Written by the team at Shoresteady Plumbing, Temperanceville, Virginia. Master plumbing licensed in Virginia and Maryland. Prices shown are typical ranges for the Eastern Shore, not a quote. Your written estimate is the only number that binds either of us.

More from the Shoresteady Plumbing blog

Drains and Sewers

Sand: The Drain Clog Nobody Warns You About Out Here

Hair you can pull out. Sand settles into the trap and the branch line and stays there, and no drain product on the shelf touches it. Wh...

Well and Water Quality

Why Faucets Fail Early on Well Water

If you are replacing faucets every few years, the faucet is probably not the problem. Here is what well water does to them and what las...

Well and Water Quality

Why Two Well Pump Quotes Can Be $2,000 Apart

Depth is the number almost nobody asks about, and it decides most of what a pump replacement costs. Here is what actually drives the pr...

Reading about it is one thing, fixing it is another

Tell us what is going on and we will get you on the schedule. Written estimate before we start, and a 2-year workmanship guarantee on every job.